The findings
Each finding names the sheet and location, the conflicting values (the evidence), and the basis — ranked by severity, always worded “flagged for your review,” never confirmed.
CRITICALflagged for your review · Sheet 12 — Pier 1 & 2 arch leg
Sheet is stamped “reinforcement still under development,” while the elevation shows bar marks and dimensions as if final.
Evidence: Red note over the outer-cage reinforcement elevation, against dimensioned bars presented as issued.
Basis: A set marked under development should not be relied on for construction QA without resolution.
HIGHflagged for your review · Sheet 7 — Bill of Reinforcement
Bill of Reinforcement printed with headers but no populated rows, while the shaft elevation and Sections A-A/B-B call out bar marks.
Evidence: Table rows blank vs. bar marks 5A, 4A drawn in the drilled-shaft detail.
Basis: Schedules and bar lists must be internally consistent with the details on the sheet.
HIGHflagged for your review · Sheet 4 — Framing / fracture control
A non-load-path-redundant tension member is not designated fracture-critical, and no CVN toughness or fracture-control requirement is invoked.
Evidence: Two-girder framing at the flagged member vs. absence of an FCM designation or CVN note.
Basis: Non-redundant steel tension members require fracture-critical designation (AASHTO LRFD 6.6.2).
MEDIUMflagged for your review · Sheet 7 — Sections A-A vs B-B
Section A-A calls a 5'-4" shaft diameter while Section B-B shows a 4'-0" casing, with no cross-reference tying the transition to the elevation.
Evidence: Section A-A ~5'-4" vs. Section B-B ~4'-0", no station reference on the elevation.
Basis: Dimensions and member sizes must resolve consistently across sections and details.
LOWflagged for your review · Sheet 7 — General notes
Concrete strength (f'c) and reinforcing grade for the drilled shaft are not stated on this sheet.
Evidence: No f'c or bar-grade callout present; verify against the general-notes sheet.
Basis: Material strengths and grades should be stated or clearly referenced.